A Journal of Observational Laryngology

Clinical observations, anecdotes, and insights which other clinicians may want to consider and test with further research.

About the Journal

How Do You Choke? Let Me Count the Ways…

By Robert W. Bastian, MD

Four examples of how the term “choking” can mean different things

When asked the reason he was calling for an appointment, a middle-aged man offered that he was “choking.” Staff not unreasonably marked on his chart that swallowing was his primary issue. In the first minutes of our time together, he focused my attention on “choking caused by swallowing.” But it shortly became clear that his choking was not “something going down the wrong pipe.” In fact, he had undergone prior xray evaluation of his swallowing function, and passed with flying colors. Rather, as he explained to me, a routine swallow would occasionally trigger a tickling sensation that set off a paroxysm of violent coughing. Bottom line? He was experiencing sensory neuropathic cough but with swallowing, especially of acidic or “scratchy” foods as one of his most prominent triggers.. He had used the word “choking” because the coughing was so intense and prolonged that he could only think of that word to describe the episode. Resolution: He was given the explanation he needed about sensory neuropathic cough and we began our search for best medication with low-dose amitriptyline…

Another “choking” patient was also initially designated as having a swallowing problem, but in his view, he ate and drank normally. During a bad cold 2 months earlier, he had initially “coughed his head off.” Although the cough had mostly subsided, he had started to awaken at night “choking,” and unable to breathe. He had endured 4 such frightening episodes across the past two months or so, thankfully with none in the past 3 weeks. Despite the recent quiescence, he was terrified it would happen again.

If a drip of saliva, or an upsurge of stomach acid had been the entire explanation, he would be expected to have simply awakened coughing. But his episodes had been much more than that — his laryngeal closure reflex was triggered, and the result was much more dramatic than coughing. He made loud inspiratory breathing noise for what seemed like an eternity but was actually about a minute. In fact, his events have a name: laryngospasm. Resolution: He was given a clear explanation of laryngospasm, an introduction to straw breathing, a suggestion that he take an acid-reducing medication for a month, and departed much relieved.

A third patient, an elderly person, gave “choking” as the reason for the visit, and the chart was so labeled. In this case it was swallowing at issue. This person had been taking longer to eat and was having to chew extra carefully. He had abandoned eating meat, gummy bread, and even mashed potatoes. His diet had become mostly soft foods, puree consistency, and liquids, because solid foods and some larger pills were getting stuck low in his throat regularly. The sensation was very uncomfortable and made him fear his airway would be blocked. A few times, he had tried to sip liquids to clear the sense of blockage, but the liquid wouldn’t pass and instead came out his nose. A videofluoroscopic swallow study confirmed that his trouble really was a disorder of the upper esophageal sphincter called cricopharyngeus dysfunction. Resolution: Initial swallowing therapy to work on ways to reduce the problem behaviorally through food choices and extra care in chewing, and also the offer of cricopharyngeus myotomy.

Yet a fourth patient, also elderly, described “choking” as the primary issue. Swallowing was also truly the problem here, too, except that it was happening mostly with liquids. Soft solids, and puree consistency worked quite well. A videofluoroscopic swallow study here showed good opening of the upper esophageal sphincter, but a pronounced tendency to pool some swallowed material in the throat after swallowing. When liquids were consumed, some tended to go into the airway—“down the wrong tube”—to cause coughing. Resolution: Swallowing strategies, thickening liquids to slow them down, and taking liquids as sips were recommended.

Patients and their doctors can work efficiently to an understanding of “choking” when the four common uses of the word are kept in mind, as described above, and summarized below.

1. I am choking. By that I mean that swallowing, (or a loud laugh, or breathing in cold air, or….) causes an abrupt tickling sensation which in turn initiates a violent attack of coughing. (Sensory neuropathic cough)

2. I am choking. By that I mean that suddenly, my throat seems to close; I can’t breathe, and I begin making loud noises when I try to breathe in. It is terrifying but seems to be over within a minute or two. (Laryngospasm)

3. I am choking. By that I mean that when I swallow, solid food and pills tend to get stuck in my throat <point to where> and sometimes I gag and try to spit to get it up. (Cricopharyngeus dysfunction with or without Zenker’s Diverticulum)

4. I am choking. By that I mean that when I swallow liquids in particular, it wants to go down the wrong tube and it makes me cough. (Aspiration)

[responsivevoice_button voice=”US English Female” buttontext=”Play”]

8 thoughts on “How Do You Choke? Let Me Count the Ways…

  1. i have some of the same symptoms of choking and coughing. I also have shortness of breath after I bend over to the ground and then stand up. A lung dr suspected acid reflux and prescribed Prilosec. I am 68 and have had Wegeners since 1981. Yes, I am one of the longest survivors. My Rheumatologist is Dr. John Cush. I was intrigued by the video where dilation was used to open the airway. I recently choked on meat and almost died. I was saved by the Himeleck (sp?) maneuver.

    I am wondering if I might be a candidate for the dilation. Ii saw it on You Tube. Is there a dr in Dallas for that?

    I am in good health but have some kidney disease. Wegeners relapsed in 2008 and 2010.

    • A few comments in reply to your questions, in no particular order. Acid reflux can cause a Chronic irritative kind of cough. It doesn’t usually cause severe and debilitating symptoms, however. Acid reflux is also not related to shortness of breath, in my experience.

      Keep in mind that Wegener’s granulomatosis affects the airway (one or more of the following: nose and sinuses, subglottis and trachea, lungs), and not so much the food way. The tendency to choke as defined as a swallowing symptom would therefore be expected to be unrelated to your Wegener’s granulomatosis. Dilation can be used for a Wegener’s-related narrowing of the subglottis and high trachea causing shortness of breath and noisy breathing. It can also be used as well for cricopharyngeus dysfunction or stricture of the esophagus unrelated to Wegener’s granulomatosis. You can see why it is so important to distinguish between the four definitions of choking in the article (I hope you find this information helpful. Please consider Dr. Bastian’s reply to be informational only, and not medical advice; don’t act without your personal physician’s input.)

  2. I must say it was hard to find your website in search results.
    You write interesting posts but you should rank your blog higher in search engines.
    If you don’t know how to do it search on youtube: how to rank a website Marcel’s

  3. Hello, I was very excited to find this site. Though I am still having a hard finding information that fits me.

    I am a 49y female. I was an LPN -was-, as I had a work related injury in 2002 that has left me 74% disabled and in constant pain. Last year while eating an apple I had my first dysphasia episode. When I swollowed the bolous made its way down my throat and the swollowing stopped leaving the bolous right behind my epiglottis. I was unable to breath and I tried to swollowing again but nothing happened my friend tried the “manouver” and managed to move the bolous of food enough so that it felt like I was breathing through a coffee straw. Pounding me on my back and me trying to gauge I was able to get it out of my throat. Sence then I have episodes a lot, but constantly. It doesn’t matter if it’s liquids or solids, it has even been my own spit.
    A month or so later I started with food bolouses that would get stuck lower and block anything from passing. My salvia during this time would come out like a garden hose and of course I can’t swollow it. I’ve tried to gauge myself but it doesn’t work and the whole ti,e this is happening it hurts horribly.
    The newest bit is I have times when I cannot initiate the swollow, it seems 5o happen more with my spit.

    I hope to find information that fits me
    Thank you

  4. Wow! Please forgive all my spelling and grammar mistakes!! I wasn’t paying attention. Here is not just the corrected copy but it corrects info and gives just a bit more.. ( if the admin could just replace it that would be awesome!)

    Hello. I am a 49yr old female. I was an LPN, -was- because I had a work related injury in 2002. It has left me 74% disabled and in constant pain. I have never had any trouble swallowing before.f

    My first dysphasia episode happened last year while I was eating an apple. When I swallowed, the bolus made its way down my throat until it was right behind my epiglottis, holding it closed. Then the swallowing just stopped, I was unable to breath and I tried to swallow again but I was unable. My friend tried the Heimlich maneuver and that managed to move the bolous of food just enough so I could get some air. It felt like I was breathing through a coffee straw. With my friend pounding on my back and me trying to gag, I was able to get it all out of my throat.

    Since then I’ve have lots of episodes, but they are not constant. It doesn’t matter if it’s liquids or solids, it has even been my own spit.
 A month or so later I started having food boluses getting stuck lower and blocking anything from passing. My salvia during this time would come out like a garden hose and of course I’m unable to swallow it. I’ve tried to gag myself but it doesn’t work and the whole time that this is happening it hurts horribly.

Now I’m having times where I am unable to initiate a swallow. It seems to happen more when I’m trying to swallow my own spit.

    I hope to find information that fits me
    Thank you

  5. I need your help. Please. I have a 20 year old son that has episodes of feeling like his throat is closing. He has even gone to the length to put his finger down his throat to help with this feeling. He drinks water to try and open his throat or tried to clear his throat . We have tried Benadryl thinking allergic reaction, Prilosec thinking gerd, anxiety meds with counseling several due to none really help. He tried a sleep study and he had quit breathing several times and now on a cpap machine.He is not overweight and in great physical shape. He has had allergy testing a scope down his throat in the office at ENT office yet nothing found. He had his iron checked was slightly low but nothing to worry about they said. Nothing has helped. I need your help. He is only 20 and shouldn’t have to live with this happening all the time. If you think something would help I am willing to drive him 4 hours to see you. Please let me know if you can help him. Also, age 16 had a pulmonary embolism and some nodules on his lungs which they ruled out at the time exposed at sometime to histoplasmosis.

    • Sorry to keep you waiting. Dr. Bastian attempts to answer questions evenings and weekends, due to his heavy clinical schedule. Keep in mind that his response is not medical advice and in response to a “hypothetical patient,” since he has not met nor examined you. With that disclaimer, here is what he said:

      “First of all I hope the problem has resolved by now. If not, what you describe has two possible interpretations. One is that your swallowing is very abnormal. If this is the correct interpretation, this would mean that you have difficulty every time you eat or drink. It would be a stable and predictable swallowing experience, not an “occasional” one. A videoendoscopic swallow study would define this easily and show the tendency to accumulate food in your throat instead of moving it all into the esophagus.

      The other is that swallowing mechanics are fine, but the act of swallowing triggers laryngospasm. It almost seems the more likely interpretation. Look at the video on laryngospasm on http://www.laryngopedia.com/laryngospasm to get the sense of that disorder.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *